Short answer: a website does not expire, but it ages. If it is awkward on a phone, if the information is no longer true, if you feel a little embarrassed giving out the address, it is time to redo it. Here are the signs not to ignore.
Five signs
- It is hard work on a phone. Tiny text, buttons too close together, pages you have to pinch to zoom. In Italy about half of web visits now come from phones, and Google assesses websites in their smartphone version.
- The information is old. Services you no longer offer, prices that have changed, photos from years ago, a team that no longer exists.
- You no longer know how to change it. Whoever built it has vanished, the system no longer updates, every small edit is a problem.
- Nobody contacts you through the website. Enquiries come from word of mouth and social media, never from there.
- It no longer represents you. Your business has grown, the website is still the one from the start.
Redoing it does not mean starting from scratch
A serious redesign does not throw everything away. It starts from what already works:
| To keep | Why |
|---|---|
| The domain | It is your address, the one clients and Google already know |
| The copy that works | It should be updated, not deleted |
| The addresses of important pages | If they change, they must be redirected to the new ones, so you do not lose visibility on Google |
| Reviews and past work | They are the proof built up over the years |
The mistake to avoid
Redoing the website just to change how it looks. A prettier website with the same problems (hidden information, hard-to-find contact details, vague copy) is still a website that does not work. The right question is not “what should it look like?”, but “what must visitors find straight away?”.
When we redo a website, that is where we start: what visitors are looking for, what they must find in a few seconds, what can be removed. The new website often has fewer pages than the old one, and works far better.
Sources
The statements in this guide are based on these sources, consulted in November 2026 (some in Italian).
- Mobile vs Desktop vs Tablet Market Share Italy — StatCounter Global Stats, 2026
- Mobile site and mobile-first indexing best practices — Google Search Central, 2026
- Redirects and Google Search — Google Search Central, 2026
- Site moves and migrations — Google Search Central, 2026